fph

en - fr - es - zh

 

ACCUEIL

 

La proposition

 

Vos réponses

   

par auteur

   

par date

   

sur l’idée de l’Alliance

   

sur l’esprit de la Charte

   

sur la Charte constitutive

   

sur les dispositifs de travail

   

sur le calendrier

   

sur vos intentions de participation

   

Autres réponses

 

RÉPONDRE AU QUESTIONNAIRE

 

Synthèses


ACCUEIL > Vos réponses

First analytical summary

par Hervé Maillot, Allié. France , 11 mai 2005

This first analytical summary attempts to produce a qualitative reflection of the answers from the first 25 participants in the consultation.

For an enormous majority (see quantitative diagrams presented on the Analytical Summaries page), the idea of the Alliance and the Constituent Charter project has been favorably to enthusiastically received, by Allies who were witnesses or actors in the first stage of the Alliance, as well as by persons not yet committed to the Alliance. The same is true for the working procedures and the calendar.

Otherwise, a few answers express some disagreement or criticism of the Charter text, the working procedures, and the calendar ; some participants express completely opposite points of view ; some participants manifest a few doubts or their need for more details on different aspects of the proposal.

The text of the Charter is sometimes seen as too theoretical and too general. This is the impression of participants wishing that a few important objectives be given distinct priority in the Charter or that well-identified events or deadlines be highlighted in the calendar. This series of answers has produced opposite points of view. One of the oppositions has to do with the influence of the FPH on the definition of the working rules and the future of the Alliance : some see the FPH as too overbearing ; others encourage it, on the contrary, to follow the path that it wishes to follow. It should be observed that a non-negligible number of participants give the impression that they are primarily addressing the FPH. There is a second opposition regarding the scale at which the Charter project is placed : while some doubt that the global approach of the Alliance meets the present challenges, feel that the Charter is Utopian, or assert that what is important is to work locally, others affirm their determination to invent a model of global society.

A third opposition lies in the perception of the Alliance as a network. This network, some declare, should be open to all, provided that a common identity is shared. Others, instead, think it should be more exclusive to significantly experienced and committed organizations. Some of the answers show that a need is felt to specify the roles, how things work, and how members are chosen for the different groups and committees set up for the facilitation, follow-up, and management of the Alliance.

Finally, a few answers express vigilance and a need for clarity on some of the ethical aspects. Vigilance on the democratic nature of the decision processes within the Alliance ; need to clarify the method (how) and the means (who) for restoring the collective memory.

GRAPHIQUES QUANTITATIFS
Key


Does this idea of an alliance respond, in its content and form of organization, to a need of our time ?
Results out of 10 answers to the questionnaire from non Allies on May 9, 2005


Do you find this proposal for a Constituent Charter suitable in its spirit and its main lines (for a new stage of the Alliance) ?
Results out of 25 answers to the quesionnaire on May 9, 2005


Constituent Charter : Points not understood or disgreed with
Results out of 25 answers to the quesionnaire on May 9, 2005


Working Procedures : Points not understood or disgreed with
Results out of 25 answers to the questionnaire on May 9, 2005


Calendar : Points not understood or disgreed with
Results out of 25 answers to the questionnaire on May 9, 2005


Participation Intentions
Results out of 25 answers to the quesionnaire on May 9, 2005

 

Avant de réagir à cette synthèsese, nous vous encourageons vivement, si vous ne l'avez pas déjà fait, de nous envoyer préalablement vos réponses au questionnaire.

 

 

TRADUCTION
- français
- Español

Autres synthèses
Deuxième synthèse |20 mai 2005 |
Troisième synthèse |8 juin 2005 |
Quatrième synthèse |4 juillet 2005 |
Cinquième synthèse |26 juillet 2005 |
Sixième synthèse |7 septembre 2005 |
Rapport final de consultation sur le projet de Charte constitutive de l’Alliance pour un monde responsable, pluriel et solidaire. |6 décembre 2005 |

 

- Alliance pour un monde responsable, pluriel et solidaire -
- Fondation Charles Léopold Mayer pour le progrès de l'Homme -